2017 First Base Rankings

Tier 1

  1. Goldschmidt
  2. Rizzo
  3. Cabrera
  4. Votto

I contemplated putting Goldschmidt into his own tier, he is the best 1st baseman in the league and will contribute in every hitting category. He has a three year average of .300 AVG 25 HR 94 R 90 RBI and 20 SB. But could easily go for more stolen bases including a career-high 32 last season. Top five pick for sure, could argue for taking him three after Trout and Betts.

Cabrera is mister consistency, has a three year average of .319 AVG 27 HR 97 RBI and 85 R scored, and had 38 HR in the 2016 season. I don’t see many signs of slowing down from Cabrera. He is being drafted early second round, and I am okay with that spot, especially with his consistency.

Tier 2

  1. Encarnacion
  2. Freeman
  3. Myers

I am a big Wil Myers fan, if you check out my hitting targets post, he has 1st and OF eligibility which is awesome and he is overall a young stud at 26. I hate that he plays for San Diego, but he will help in all categories besides hitting! With 30 HR 90 RBI power, he will also be able to score 90 R and steal 25 bases. His biggest problem has been his lack of health over the last four seasons with last year being his first full season.

*Posey/Lucroy-If you are using either of these guys as a first baseman this is the Tier I would take them in.

Tier 3

  1. Abreau
  2. Hosmer

Jose Abreu has been nothing but consistent in his three-year MLB career, posting a .300 AVG 30 HR and 100 RBI I think he is a steal at his 62 ADP. I was close to moving him up to tier two. He is in a great hitters ballpark and should have some runners ahead of him with Tim Anderson and Melky Cabrera hitting one and two.

Tier 4

  1. Chris Davis
  2. Hanley Ramirez
  3. Carlos Santana

After a tough stretch of injury filled years Hanley was able to stay healthy for the 2016 season playing in 147 games. With Ortiz leaving, I would assume he is going to get the bulk of the DH work in Boston. Which may be the best thing for him and his career. After putting up a .286 AVG with 30 HR 111 RBI and 81 R scored last season he very well could replicate those numbers in that great lineup. With his ~80 ADP, I would be okay taking him in the 7th or 8th round.

Dynasty League Stashes

  1. Josh Bell (PIT)
  2. Dan Vogelbach (SEA)
  3. Cody Bellinger (LAD)


If you like what you are reading please give me a like and share!


Leave a Reply